When I first watched Detective Pikachu back in 2019, I had mixed feelings—like many fans. On one hand, seeing Pokémon in live-action was mind-blowing. The visual effects were stunning, and the world felt real. But something was missing. The movie focused on solving a mystery, which felt more like a Hollywood gimmick than a tribute to what makes Pokémon special. Don't get me wrong, the underground battle scene and Tim's attempt to catch a Cubone were glimpses of greatness. But overall, it sidelined the core elements: adventure, bonding, and growth. The heart of Pokémon isn't crime-solving; it's about trainers and their Pokémon evolving together through challenges. That's why I believe a live-action TV series—not another movie—is the way to go. It's got the time and space to capture the magic that Detective Pikachu missed.

A TV show offers what a movie simply can't: room to breathe. Think about it—Pokémon is all about progression. In the games and anime, we watch trainers start from scratch, face setbacks, and slowly build unbreakable bonds. A two-hour film has to compress all that into a highlight reel, risking clichés or shallow character arcs. But a series? It lets stories unfold naturally. Imagine following a rookie trainer over a season:

• Episode 1: Choosing a starter Pokémon, maybe a rebellious Charmander or a loyal Bulbasaur.

• Episode 5: Losing a big battle and learning humility.

• Episode 10: Training montages where the Pokémon evolves, both literally and emotionally.

That gradual buildup is everything. It's what makes us cry when Ash's Pikachu refuses to evolve or cheer when a underdog Pokémon wins against the odds. A show can dive deep into themes like friendship, responsibility, and even loss—things Detective Pikachu glossed over. Plus, with multiple episodes, we could explore diverse Pokémon from different generations, not just the poster-child Pikachu. From quirky regional variants to legendary beasts, every creature could get its moment to shine.

Now, let's talk about Detective Pikachu's missteps. The movie's premise felt like a bait-and-switch. Instead of adapting a classic journey like Pokémon Red or Blue, it went for a detective story—a genre that doesn't align with Pokémon's soul. Sure, the film grossed over $400 million, but it treated Pokémon as props rather than partners. The focus on solving a mystery meant sidelining iconic elements like gym battles, training arcs, and that addictive sense of adventure. It was like ordering a burger and getting a salad—fine, but not what you craved.

What's worse, Detective Pikachu set a risky precedent. It suggested that Pokémon needs Hollywood tropes to appeal to mainstream audiences. But that's BS. The franchise's longevity comes from its emotional depth, not flashy concepts. A live-action adaptation should honor that, not reinvent it. Thankfully, rumors hint that Netflix is developing a series with Joe Henderson (of Lucifer fame) attached. If done right, this could be the redemption arc we deserve—a show prioritizing character-driven stories over spectacle.

So, what would a successful live-action series look like? Picture this:

• Format: Episodic adventures with an overarching plot, similar to the anime.

• Focus: A trainer's journey—capturing Pokémon, battling rivals, and striving to become a champion.

• Emphasis: Slow-burn relationships. For example, an episode where a Pokémon gets injured, forcing the trainer to nurse it back to health and strengthening their bond.

This approach mirrors the games' structure, which fans love. It also allows for world-building. We could explore regions like Kanto or Johto in depth, meet diverse characters, and even tackle mature themes—like what happens when a trainer loses a Pokémon forever. That emotional weight is what Detective Pikachu lacked. It played it safe with a family-friendly mystery, but Pokémon has always been about more than just fun; it's about growth.

Looking ahead, a Netflix series has huge potential. With streaming, creators aren't limited by runtime or box-office pressures. They can take risks—maybe adapting lesser-known stories or introducing new Pokémon seamlessly. And let's be real: after Detective Pikachu, fans are hungry for something authentic. A series that celebrates the franchise's roots could be a game-changer. It's not about ditching animation; it's about expanding Pokémon's reach without losing its heart.

In the end, Detective Pikachu was a missed opportunity. But it taught us a valuable lesson: live-action Pokémon can work, but only if it stays true to what makes the franchise beloved. A TV series isn't just a better format—it's the only format that can do justice to Pokémon's legacy. So here's hoping the Netflix project delivers. Because after years of waiting, we deserve a adaptation that feels like coming home.